top of page

Writer's Reviews - Crime and Punishment: Fyodor Dostoevsky

The critical-literary analyses offered by WriTribe are a thousand words long. Each has been compiled with the intention of providing writers not only with a general introduction to the works presented, but also to reveal the added value inherent in each of them. 1,000 words go far beyond mere criticism or superficial praise; they are intended to point you to one or more secret elements, showing you what narrative techniques are masterfully employed by the author of the work in question. Written with the unique perspective of an author for authors, reviews aim to point out to you what added value you can glean from twenty literary classics. With this in mind, choosing the reading best suited to your need will prove much easier.



cover of Crime and Punishment by Fyodor Dostoevsky

 

CRIME AND PUNISHMENT (1866)

Fyodor Dostoevsky


The work at a glance

Crime and Punishment is the story of young student Rodion Romanovič Raskol'nikov, expelled from the university, who lives in St. Petersburg in poverty but considers himself a true intellectual. Raskol'nikov is a proud and ambitious character, to the point that he is so convinced of his own superiority that he goes so far as to theorize that some people are so exceptional that they are above common moral norms and therefore have the right to commit even crimes for the good of the community.


On the strength of this conviction Raskol'nikov decides to commit murder. He plans and kills both an old moneylender, Alyanna Ivanovna, and the latter's sister, Lizaveta, who has discovered him fortuitously. The young man attempts to disguise the true nature of the crime by stealing some valuables so that it is assumed that there was a consequence of robbery. But after committing the crime something changes in him inexorably: Raskol'nikov is seized with remorse, begins to be tormented by his conscience, and struggles to conceal his guilt, even though he is pressured by his neighbor, policeman Porfiriy Petrovič, who begins to investigate the case despite finding no concrete evidence against him.


At this point Raskol'nikov meets Sonia Marmeladova, a young prostitute, and develops a deep relationship with her. She becomes his confidante and helps him confront his crimes, but also his guilt. As the psychological pressure on the young man becomes more and more pressing, Raskol'nikov relents and confesses his crime to Sonia and an investigator, Zametov. Eventually Raskol'nikov redeems himself, admits responsibility for his crime, and turns himself in, preparing to serve his sentence.


The novel deals with profound themes concerning human nature, justice, morality, and the complexities of the mind, but it is above all the protagonist's evolution and his quest for redemption that constitute the central element of Crime and Punishment. Dostoevsky's masterpiece is considered one of the pillars of world literature and is a landmark in history for several reasons, but particularly because it deeply investigates human psychology.


This happens precisely with the story of the protagonist, Raskol'nikov, whose complexities of the mind, inner conflicts and those moral torments that an individual who has committed murder may experience are explored by Dostoevsky. Another significant element that emerges from the novel concerns the way 19th-century Russian society is depicted, revealing its contradictions and inequalities. Indeed, the protagonist, prey to his torments, will find himself wandering around St. Petersburg encountering outcasts, whether perpetrators or victims, with whom he will come into relationship, and from these scenes Dostoevsky will highlight themes dear to him such as poverty, despair and social alienation.


 

What you can learn from reading this work:


  1. Psychological depth of the characters

  2. Use of dialogue and narrative rhythm

  3. Ability to introspect in characterizing the main characters

  4. Exploration of universal themes

  5. Reflection on society


 

A wide range of literary and thematic elements coexist in Crime and Punishment that can inspire and influence a writer on his or her own path of growth and development of different skills on the literary, stylistic and content levels. Reading Fyodor Dostoevsky's Crime and Punishment, in fact, can be useful and functional for many reasons. Starting precisely from the deep psychological analysis of the main character, the protagonist Raskol'nikov, it will be possible to imagine for one's story increasingly complex characters with different emotional facets and deep motivations, thus making them more engaging for readers.


In terms of structure and style Crime and Punishment is an excellent example of storytelling that follows a precise narrative structure. By analyzing Dostoevsky's writing, an author can acquire greater skills in constructing a compelling story due primarily to the effective use of dialogue and excellent narrative pacing-absence of deadlocks-a skill now widely recognized in the great Russian writer.


The novel explores universal themes such as morality, guilt, forgiveness and redemption, and the meaning of life and death, all of which can come in handy for a writer who intends to analyze and address important issues within his or her own story, adding greater depth and meaning to the content. The novel's narrative is based, as we have seen, largely on the introspections of the characters, showing their inner thoughts and dilemmas.


This can be a stimulus for those who wish to really explore their characters in depth and flesh out the motivations that lead them to act in a certain way, as well as their ideological and moral convictions. This innovative psychological approach has also had a significant impact on the development of what is called psychological realism in the literary field.


Crime and Punishment is also a firm and decisive critique of Russian society of the time and its social inequalities. This kind of reflection within the novel could inspire the writer to develop himself a critical and nonconforming view of the social reality in which he lives, thus avoiding a kind of flattening of the context in which the story is set.


Reading Crime and Punishment, it almost seems as if Dostoevsky invites readers to develop a kind of empathy for the protagonist, despite the fact that he is guilty of a horrendous crime, murder, as if the death of others is an extreme form of justice and social and existential redemption. This could come in handy in the construction of characters who may yes be complex and even morally ambiguous, but still manage to capture a kind of sympathy from the reading public.


Conclusions

Crime and Punishment has always been considered a seminal, almost inescapable work that has influenced the literature and authors of even later eras, both in Russia and internationally, including Franz Kafka, Albert Camus and Jean-Paul Sartre. Dostoevsky is now recognized in his own right as one of the leading exponents of 19th-century Russian literature, and Crime and Punishment as one of his most celebrated and appreciated works. His ability to explore the contradictions of the human soul and present complex moral dilemmas has made this novel a milestone in the history of literature, which is why, to this day, it continues to be read and studied all over the world because its universal relevance makes it a timeless work.

Comments


Copyright WriTribe - All rights reserved

bottom of page